tuberculossis programe evaluation and critical review in gandhinagar district

Dr. Rajnikant K. Patel 
M.O. PHC Uvarsad 21/07/2008Initial home visit by health worker along with
" Disease Burden of Tuberculosis in Gandhinagar"supervisor which make verification of address. Social
 determinant and surrounding environment which
Introduction :provides sustainable supported environment to TB
 case giving more emphasis on health education.
Tuberculosis is a chronic infectious disease withDecreases spread of disease in community it makes
varying clinical manifestation as likely affecting variouspatient more self reliant and self determined. Family
system of body.members are motivated for patient's support and
 compliance. Regular intake of Drugs can make
- Ø Organism was discovered 100 years ago andpatients free from TB. We realizes the community
still availability of effective drugs and vaccine itmembers that what importance the role of IP phase.
remains a public health problem globally.Initial 12 week treatment give symptomatic relief and
- Ø "Non - specific" determinants of TB Diseasedecrease infectivity that leads to less numbers of
spread, it but shown improvent in the standard ofcases in the community. If patient is migrant then by
living and quality of life has declined death Rate ingiving address to another TU. The treatment should
developed countries thus causing a more impact inbe started at patient's residential place.
reducing the Burden of TB Disease in that area. 
- Ø It kills more Adults than any other infectious- Ø If Dot's centre is far away accessibility is
disease especially productive age group of 15-49making easier for drugs near by center for patient's
years.accommodation and needs.
- Ø Globally 20,000 people infected per day 5000- Ø Suspected cases among family members who
develops disease in one day and 1 death occurshave cough within 1 week are examined for sputum
within 1 ½ minute.leads to early detection of cases in family and
 surrounding area.
Mortality and Morbidity : 
 How many children they have are surveyed and
- Ø In 1962, NTCP was launched but due to poorconfirmed during home visit and by doing weight of
patient compliance; Diagnostic criteria was not basedthat children and assured Isoniazid prophylaxis to
on sputum microscopy, sensitivity and specificity ofchildren below 6 years regularly by preventing
diagnostic test was not there.tuberculosis incidence in children.
- Ø In NTCP area there were 35 case per 1,00,000 
population of sputum positive during 1977 to 1991Regular visit by STS and STLS of poor working PHC.
sputum positive case was less and extra pulmonaryRegular visit by medical officer and supervisor and
and X ray positive case were high.checking of box with treatment card. Field visit of TB
- Ø Standardize data abstraction in NTP Districtpatient and evaluating dots by asking indirect question
indicates that 8% of patients were smear positiveto them.
less than half the proportion in RNTCP Districts. 
- Ø In NTCP Ratio of sputum positive case toDiagnostic algorithm displayed in medical officer room
sputum negative case was 1:3.6 which Declines toand laboratory diagnostic algorithm displayed in lab
1:2.5 in 1999 after launching RNTCP in country.technician room. During routine surveillance activities
- Ø Patient compliance was less in NTCP and lackm.p.w. keep sputum cup with them and give to
of follow up and supervision made programme lesssymptomatic patients for further dignosis by sputum
effective and out come were poor.microscopy.
- Ø In NTCP single Drug therapy had caused 
resistance to many Drugs.Laboratory technician and pharmacist prepared a
- Ø The programme was not Funded by externalfollow up list and give to all MPW and FHW of PHC
agencies like world bank made less availability ofwith referral slip and tell them for regular sputum
human resources and logistics.follow up of patients and asked to start continuation
- Ø Drug supply was irregular, erratic andphase within seven days of follow up result. They
inadequate.are drawing the attention of medical officer who are
- Ø Sanitorium base treatment made morenot coming up for follow up examination.
psycho-social effect to the patieat and community. 
And Not improving the status of the community.Regular meeting of pharmacist and lab technician
 block level by DTO and BHO and giving them all
Due to above pitfall in programme morbidity andlogistic supply including drugs for one month and
mortality was still high. So, RNTCP was launched inreview the progrmme at grass root level.
1993 in Mehsana District as a pilot project. In 
Gandhinagar RNTCP was started in 2000.   - Ø Those patients whose sputum are negative are
 tracked down and re diagnosis is done. The patients
- Ø Total TB patients Diagnosed in 2005 were 488,who are negative during re diagnosis of sputum
470, 417, 434 quarter 1, 2, 3, 4 Respectively.examination but having symptomatic complain
- Ø Total TB patients Diagnosed in 2006 were 463,continue are gathered at PHC and send to district TB
474, 500, 455 in quarter 1, 2, 3, 4 Respectively.centre for X-ray examination along with worker in
- Ø Total TB patients Diagnosed in 2007 were 475,PHC vehicle thus by finding the extrapumonary cases
542, 500, 427 in quarter 1, 2, 3, 4 Respectively.and started to them on RNTCP cat III regime.
- Ø It shows that there is gradual Increase in- Ø Monitoring of weight - The patients whose
number of TB patients diagnosed in comparison toweight was not increased are specially focused and
past year 2005 but still there is decrease in Numbercare to be taken for DOT compromised or not. The
of TB patient in quarter 4 in each year as comparedpoor patients are benefited by social welfare
to other quarter of year.department by collaborating through them.
- Ø Annualized total case detection per one lac- Ø Regular attending of M.O. meeting at District
population ranges from 120 to 145 but it averageslevel by DTO and encouraged who had done good
around 130.work and strict action are taken against who have
- Ø Number of smear positive cases diagnosed inworked poorly.
2007 was 370, 411, 373, 315 in quarter 1, 2, 3, 4- Ø World TB day are celebrated at District and
respectively.Taluka level. Reward are given who has done best
- Ø Number of smear positive cases diagnosed inwork in RNTCP. The reward are given to all caders,
2006 was 361, 424, 366, 358 in quarter 1, 2, 3, 4workers, lab. Tech., Pharmacist, STS/STLS , M.O. and
respectively.BHO in presence of political leaders and District
- Ø Number of smear positive cases diagnosed inadministrators.
2005 was 371, 399, 358, 331 in quarter.- Ø The best DOTs worker and best cured patient
- Ø Total no. of smear positive cases 1455 in 2005who had taken treatment regularly are also rewarded
increased to 1469 in 2007 showing marginal increase.at Taluka level.
- Ø New smear positive cases Registered for- Ø Exhibition of TB Disease related information in
treatment in 2005. Were 200, 216, 207, 191 in quarterforms of posters, pamphlet IEC activities by various
1, 2, 3, 4 respectively.media during "GRAM SABHA" at village level.
- Ø In 2006 were 207, 212, 212, 213 in quarter 1, 2,- Ø The patients provider meeting are held at PHC
3, 4 respectively.every 3 months attended by District level staff.
- Ø In 2007 were 212, 212, 208, 209 in quarter 1, 2,- Ø N.G.O. are involved in the RNTC programme
3, 4 respectively.which are increased from 2 in 2005 to 6 in 2007.
 public private partnership along with private doctors
- v New Smear Negative cases initiated on treatmentand private lab technician are increased from 2 in
category III in 2005 was 101, 81, 46, 59 quarter 1, 2,2004 to 12 in 2007.
3, 4 respectively.- Ø Rootine immunization of B.C.G. coverage around
  65-70% had done impact on TB meningitis and Millary
- Ø In 2006 was 61, 65, 74, 52 in quarter 1, 2, 3, 4TB cases in children.
respectively.- Ø Social mobilization is done by involving the local
- Ø In 2007 was 66, 58, 59, 49 in quarter 1, 2, 3, 4leaders and competition in school children for TB
respectively.awareness in particular area and community by
- Ø Total new smear Negative case was invarious types of IEC programme and try to change
2005-287 in 2006-252. In 2007-232 it's Decrease yearthe mind set of community and individual that TB is
wise.not a social stigma now and responsibility of every
- Ø Extra pulmonary cases remains same in 2005citizen to fight against tuberculosis.
and 2007 and decreased in 2006.- Ø ICTC centre works for TB - HIV con-infection.
  
- v Retreatment case No. of sputum smear positiveAbove all programme had made success of this
patients started on category II regime.programme in best way in Gandhinagar District by
 performing more then 70% detection rate more than
- Ø In 2005 was 92, 81, 82, 114 in quarter 1, 2, 3, 490% sputum conversion rate and more then 85%
respectively.cure rate.    
- Ø In 2006 was 104, 107, 119, 106 in quarter 1, 2,Limitation of Date Bases
3, 4 respectively. 
- Ø In 2007 was 112, 129, 127 & 82 in quarter- ü Data are not showing that how many
1, 2, 3, 4 respectively.suspected were examined and from them how many
It is increase from 369 in 2005 to 450 in 2007 itare not come for treatment.
suggest more Failure. Relapse and defaulter cases are- ü Date does not shows how many patients are
increased may be due to lack of supervision, not visitnot put earlier on Dot's regime and what was the
done by MPW. Not retrieval action was carried outprognosis in that type of cases.
etc.- ü Data does not shows that how many cases
- Ø Paediatric cases out of New cases were inare treated as sputum negative are re sputum
2005-46 in 2006-61 and in 2007-88. Due to availabilityexamination was done.
of paediatric boxes the more patients are initiated or- ü Data does not show that why retreatment
started on Treatment in 2007.cases are increased it is due to Dot's compromised or
- Ø Cure rate is increased from 83% in 2005 tolesser effective drugs or other reason etc.
89% 2006.- ü Data does not show how many patients are
- Ø Failure rate is decrease from 2.6 to 2.2%.restarted by retrieval action within 2 month period.
- Ø Death rate is increased from 3.5 to 4.7 in 2006.- ü Data does not show actual prevalence of
- Ø Defaulter rate is Increased from 6-7% todisease in the community.
11-13% in 2005.Though the last survey was carried out in 1958 by
- Ø Treatment completed case increased aroundChennai for actual prevalence of Infection and
from 80% to 85% in 2005 to 2006.incidence of disease which is followed in RNTCP
 programme for giving goals, targets and Norms to
- v Seasonal Trends:achieve.
   
          No seasonal Trends is seen. But due- ü Data does not show actual annual risk of
to some reason less cases are found in quarter fourInfection according to that the occurrence of cases
of any year in comparision to other quarters of year.pulmonary, extra pulmonary and retreatment. Cases
 yet. Some cases are missing.
- Ø Socio- environmental and economical factors- ü Data does not shown that how many patients
leads to more occurrence and spread of diseases.whose one sputum was only given and they are
In Dehgam Taluka of Gandhinagar District due topositive but they are not come again to the health
more presence of lower socio-economic group casescare system.
are more seen in that area as compared to other- ü Data does not shows that how many patients
Taluka of District.have not given their last follow up and they are
- Ø Though Gandhinagar urban area have moredeclared as cured or treatment completed.
population despite the occurrence of cases are less inData does not show Multi-Drug resistance cases.
urban area. 
- Ø It is mostly seen in poor people, less income 
lower hygienic and sanitation practices and overSource -          Central TB Division
crowding area.                        Health and F.W.
                         New Delhi.
Intervention                        India.